Derek Hough vs. Hayley Erbert Who'd You Rather?! (Who Wore It Better Edition)

Derek Hough pulled off a masterclass in surprise by wearing the same short dress as Hayley Erbert during their performance, earning cheers from fans and confusion—or at least awkwardness—between the couple. As their duet went awry, Derek’s clever timing and Hayley’s comedic partnering kept the audience on its toes—and for fans, it was a reminder of just how much Derek has grown as an artist. Meanwhile, fans were quick to weigh in on a fan poll about who would rather have something go wrong: Derek Hough or Hayley Erbert?